When the Philadelphia Union next step onto the field on Saturday, Nov. 21, in Foxborough, Massachusetts, they will enter the Audi 2026 MLS Cup Playoffs as the sixth seed in the Eastern Conference for the third time in club history.

The Union previously entered the playoffs as the sixth seed in 2016 and 2018, falling in the knockout round on both occasions.

Interestingly, the Union have also entered the postseason as the top seed three times in club history.

So being someone that enjoys diving into historical stats and data, I dove into the rabbit hole checking the league’s almanac and a few other places.

Historically, the sixth seed has not been a position of hope for clubs looking to hoist the MLS Cup at the end of the season. Since the league expanded to a 34-game regular season in 2011, and even before that, no team seeded sixth has won MLS Cup, let alone reached the final.

Bruno Damiani and Milan Iloski. Photo: Philadelphia Union

Yes, the New York Red Bulls reached the final in 2024 as the seventh seed before falling 2-1 to the LA Galaxy. However, the lowest seed to win MLS Cup has been the fourth seed, with the LA Galaxy (2005), Real Salt Lake (2009), Seattle Sounders (2016) and New York City FC (2021) all accomplishing the feat.

So, while I was looking through this information for an upcoming episode of The One Team We Agree On, I started to wonder: Why even write this article?

Historically, Philly stands no chance based on the data and all that jazz, right?

Perhaps.

But nothing about this season has been normal.

Indiana Vassilev and Cavan Sullivan. Photo: Philadelphia Union

The Union started the season with just seven points through their first 15 matches. However, once interim head coach Ryan Richter took over, Philadelphia earned 43 of a possible 57 points (13-2-4) following the World Cup break.

To put that into perspective, only Supporters’ Shield winner Nashville SC, which broke the league’s single-season points record with 77, earned more points than the Union following the World Cup break, collecting 44.

So, hypothetically, is it possible?

I’m going to break it down, have a little fun, and see if maybe, just maybe, the Union could become the first sixth seed in MLS history to win it all.

First Round: New England Revolution

Let’s look at their first-round matchup against the New England Revolution.

New England beat the Union both times they faced off in 2026, winning 2-1 in both contests. However, during the final stretch of six matches against Chicago, Charlotte, New England, Nashville, Cincinnati and Toronto, Richter repeatedly said the New England match was the one in which he felt his club wasn’t at its best.

So, while first-year head coach Marko Mitrović deserves tons of credit for getting this Revolution squad right, it is not out of the realm of possibility that the Union could advance.

In their latest meeting, moments of brilliance from Carles Gil and Dor Turgeman were enough to secure a 2-1 home victory for New England. However, the Union kept fighting after Neil Pierre’s header beat Matt Turner, with both Agustín Anello and Frankie Westfield missing late chances to level the match.

Frankie Westfield. Photo: Emily Wallace-Sutton

While that might not bring you much comfort, the Revs are coming off a 1-0 loss to Orlando City after previously falling 2-1 at home to Inter Miami.

Both opponents have star power, but without getting too far into the weeds with data and statistics, let’s consider the possibilities.

The Union could get a win at home and then take one of the two potential road matches. After all, since Richter took over, Philadelphia has lost just once on the road following its trip to Cincinnati.

So, is advancing really out of the realm of possibility?

I don’t think so.

Eastern Conference Semifinals: Inter Miami or Columbus Crew

Let’s say, for the sake of this article, that the Union advance. Then what?

Well, they would play the winner of Inter Miami and the Columbus Crew in the Eastern Conference semifinals.

Everyone and their brother will pick Messi and Miami to advance, but I would argue that the Crew are more than capable of pulling off a seventh-seed upset over a second seed.

Laurent Courtois’s side has won five matches in a row heading into the playoffs. Sure, Inter Miami is strong once again, but the club has struggled at NU Stadium at times this year, and its defense hasn’t exactly been the greatest.

Lionel Messi and Frankie Westfield. Photo: Emily Wallace-Sutton

If Miami advances, the Union would have another opportunity to do something they haven’t accomplished since Messi arrived: beat Inter Miami.

Perhaps, in a one-off playoff match, Philly finally breaks through.

The matchup that might look more favorable on paper is Columbus. Sure, the Union would host, but I would be wary of this Crew side. In fact, Columbus is my dark horse as the seventh seed to make a run to the final.

For argument’s sake, let’s say the Union find a way to advance again.

Eastern Conference Final: Nashville SC

Without a doubt, I would imagine the Union would face Nashville SC at GEODIS Park in front of a sold-out crowd.

The Union played Nashville to scoreless draws in both meetings this season, and while Nashville rested its starters for the most part, this would undoubtedly be Philadelphia’s toughest challenge yet.

Neil Pierre. Photo: Philadelphia Union

Nashville hasn’t lost at home this year, and probable MLS Coach of the Year and former Philadelphia assistant B.J. Callaghan would certainly pull out all the stops.

My initial thought is that the Union’s run ends here.

But let’s have some fun.

What if the Union somehow beat the juggernaut and advanced to MLS Cup?

MLS Cup Final: Who Comes Out of the West?

Who would they face from the Western Conference?

Most likely Vancouver, St. Louis City or FC Dallas.

Maybe Houston, LAFC or Portland makes a run. Or perhaps Bruce Arena and the San Jose Earthquakes find a way to get there.

Imagine FC Dallas and the Union matching up again, with players from the 2024 MLS NEXT Cup in Frisco potentially crossing paths once more. Sure, that would make for a great storyline.

I could see Vancouver or St. Louis City making it to the final, but the fun part of the MLS Cup Playoffs is that there is always a team that gets hot at the right time and makes an unexpected run.

Why couldn’t that team be Philadelphia?

Health and Depth Could Determine Everything

A lot will depend on how healthy Richter’s squad is when players return from the international window.

One of the biggest questions is whether Milan Iloski will be available and fully recovered.

If so, that would be a major boost.

Cavan Sullivan, Danley Jean Jacques, Milan Iloski. Photo: Philadelphia Union

At times during the absences of Iloski and Cavan Sullivan, the Union struggled to find goals, although their recent 4-1 victory over Toronto on Decision Day showed what this attack can do when things start clicking.

With the news that the U.S. U-17 squad has withdrawn from the 2026 FIFA U-17 World Cup due to safety concerns, forward Malik Jakupović will return to the Union for the playoffs, providing another option off the bench.

That would potentially give Philadelphia Iloski, Bruno Damiani, Jakupović and Alladoh as attacking options. If the coaching staff chooses to do so, Quinn Sullivan could also be deployed in a striker role.

Malik Jakupovic. Photo: Emily Wallace-Sutton

Either way, as we all know, having a healthy Iloski would be a significant boost to the Union’s chances of making a deep playoff run.

Another important piece will be the status of Andre Blake.

During his latest press conference, Richter mentioned that he didn’t believe Blake’s injury was anything too serious and that holding him out was more of a precautionary measure.

Still, potentially missing the three-time MLS Goalkeeper of the Year during the playoffs would be a major blow.

Andre Blake. Photo: Emily Wallace-Sutton

Sure, Blake might not be the same goalkeeper he was in 2022, but he has shown, especially during the second half of this season, that his leadership remains invaluable.

And on any given night, he can still remind everyone why he is arguably one of the greatest goalkeepers in league history.

Can the Union Really Pull It Off?

We’ll see how everything shakes out.

The deck might be stacked against the Union, and history certainly isn’t on their side.

But as we’ve written about time and time again since the World Cup break, there is something different about this Philadelphia team under Richter.

Ryan Richter. Photo: Philadelphia Union

A club that looked dead in the water after 15 matches has turned into one of the hottest teams in MLS.

And while the historical data suggests that a sixth seed has little chance of lifting the MLS Cup, the beautiful thing about the playoffs is that history doesn’t determine what happens on the field.

Sometimes, all it takes is a team getting hot at the right time, a few timely goals, a big save from its goalkeeper and a little bit of luck.

And if there’s one thing this Union team has shown us over the past few months, it’s that you can never count out an underdog.

Main article photo: Philadelphia Union

One response to “Can the Philadelphia Union Make an MLS Cup Run?”

  1. We can dream…

    Like

Leave a Reply

Trending